Skip to content

Dispute and risk monitoring programs

Learn the programs the card networks use to monitor disputes, fraud, and business risk.

Overview

The card networks require every business that accepts cards to keep disputes and fraud low. In addition, they require that you sell legal, accurately described goods and services.

Each network enforces these requirements through monitoring programs. A business that crosses a program's threshold is placed in the program. Depending on the program, the network charges non-compliance assessments, removes protections such as the 3D Secure liability shift, or requires a remediation plan until the problem is fixed.

These non-compliance assessments can be passed through to you and your merchants.

There are two categories of programs:

CategoryHow it works
Dispute and fraud programsThese programs measure disputes and fraud against set thresholds, usually as a monthly ratio such as disputes divided by transactions.
Risk and integrity programsThese programs look at what a business sells and how they sell it. A single violation can trigger an investigation.

Visa

Visa runs three major monitoring programs.

ProgramTypeWhat it monitors
Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program (VAMP)Dispute and fraudDisputes, fraud reports, and card testing on card-not-present payments.
Visa Secure Excessive Fraud ProgramDispute and fraudFraud on payments authenticated with 3D Secure.
Visa Integrity Risk Program (VIRP)Risk and integrityIllegal transactions and high-integrity-risk business types.

Visa non-compliance assessments can be passed through to you and your merchants.

Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program (VAMP)

VAMP is Visa's global program for monitoring fraud, disputes, and card testing. It covers card-not-present Visa payments, both domestic and cross-border. Card-present payments aren't included.

How the VAMP ratio is calculated

VAMP ratio
VAMP ratio = (fraud reports + disputes) ÷ settled transactions
InputWhat it countsVisa record
Fraud reportsEvery fraud report an issuing bank files on a card-not-present payment.TC40
DisputesEvery dispute on a card-not-present payment, whether the reason is fraud or not.TC15
Settled transactionsEvery settled card-not-present sale.TC05

All three inputs are counts from the same calendar month.

Keep these rules in mind when you estimate your own ratio:

  • A fraudulent payment can count twice. If the issuing bank files a fraud report and then a dispute for the same payment, Visa counts both.
  • Disputes resolved through a pre-dispute solution, such as Rapid Dispute Resolution (RDR), are excluded. A fraud report filed on the same payment still counts.
  • Fraud reports that qualify for Compelling Evidence 3.0 are excluded.
  • Refunding a payment doesn't remove a fraud report or dispute that Visa already received.

VAMP thresholds

A business is Excessive when it meets both thresholds in a month:

CriteriaThreshold
VAMP ratio1.5% or higher (150 basis points)
Monthly count of fraud reports and disputes1,500 or more

These thresholds apply in the United States and Canada. The ratio threshold was 2.2% until April 1, 2026.

The following examples show how the ratio and the monthly count work together.

Settled transactionsCount (fraud reports + disputes)Count is 1,500 or more?VAMP ratio (count ÷ settled transactions)Ratio is 1.5% or higher?Result
100,0001,100 + 900 = 2,000Yes2,000 ÷ 100,000 = 2.0%YesExcessive. Both thresholds are met.
200,000900 + 700 = 1,600Yes1,600 ÷ 200,000 = 0.8%NoThreshold not met. The ratio is below 1.5%.
20,000250 + 150 = 400No400 ÷ 20,000 = 2.0%YesThreshold not met. The count is below 1,500.

Card testing (enumeration)

VAMP also monitors card testing, which is formally known by Visa as enumeration. In a card testing attack, a fraudster runs many small authorizations through a checkout to find valid card numbers.

VAMP enumeration ratio
Enumeration ratio = enumerated authorizations ÷ all authorizations

Both sides of the ratio count approved and declined authorizations. Visa identifies enumerated authorizations with its own detection model.

A business is placed in the program when it meets both thresholds in a month:

CriteriaThreshold
Enumeration ratio20% or higher
Enumerated authorizations300,000 or more

Visa Secure Excessive Fraud Program (3DS)

The Visa Secure Excessive Fraud Program monitors fraud on payments that were authenticated with 3D Secure (3DS). The program applies only in the United States, to domestic payments on US-issued Visa cards.

Normally, a successful 3DS authentication shifts liability for fraud disputes from the business to the issuing bank. This program removes that protection from a business with too much authenticated fraud. For more information, see 3DS liability shift.

Unlike VAMP, this program uses dollar amounts:

3DS fraud rate
3DS fraud rate = fraud amount on 3DS-authenticated payments ÷ sales amount of 3DS-authenticated payments

A business is placed in the program when it meets both thresholds in a month:

CriteriaThreshold
Fraud amount on 3DS-authenticated payments$75,000 or more
3DS fraud rate0.9% or higher

Fraud reports count in the month Visa receives them. For example, the February calculation uses 3DS-authenticated payments captured in February and fraud reports received in February, including reports for payments captured in January.

3DS authenticated sales3DS fraud amount3DS fraud rateResult
$10,000,000$95,0000.95%Both thresholds are met.
$5,000,000$60,0001.2%Threshold not met. The fraud amount is below $75,000.
$12,000,000$80,0000.67%Threshold not met. The fraud rate is below 0.9%.

Visa doesn't charge a fee under this program. Instead, a business in the program loses the fraud liability shift on domestic 3DS payments, so the issuing banks can file fraud disputes on authenticated payments until the business exits the program.

Visa Integrity Risk Program (VIRP)

The Visa Integrity Risk Program makes sure that acquirers and merchants keep illegal transactions out of the Visa network. In addition, it enforces proper controls over higher-risk business types.

Visa can place a business in the Visa Integrity Risk Program for:

  • Processing illegal transactions, such as the sale of counterfeit goods or illegal drugs.
  • Operating in a high-integrity-risk category without being registered.
  • Using a merchant category code (MCC) or business description that doesn't match what it sells.
  • Using deceptive marketing practices.
  • Processing payments on behalf of another, undisclosed business.

Mastercard

Mastercard has five programs to monitor risk:

ProgramTypeWhat it monitors
Excessive Chargeback Program (ECP)Dispute and fraudChargebacks of any kind.
Excessive Fraud Merchant (EFM)Dispute and fraudFraud chargebacks on online payments.
Questionable Merchant Audit Program (QMAP)Dispute and fraudCollusive or fraudulent activity by the business itself.
Business Risk Assessment and Mitigation (BRAM)Risk and integrityIllegal or brand-damaging transactions.
Global Risk Investigation Program (GRIP)Risk and integrityRule violations that fall outside the other programs.

Mastercard non-compliance assessments can be passed through to you and your merchants.

Excessive Chargeback Program (ECP)

The Excessive Chargeback Program monitors a business's total chargebacks. It has two levels:

  • Excessive Chargeback Merchant (ECM).
  • High Excessive Chargeback Merchant (HECM).

How the chargeback ratio is calculated

Mastercard chargeback ratio
Chargeback ratio = chargebacks received this month ÷ transactions from the previous month

Both inputs are counts of Mastercard activity. Mastercard assigns a chargeback to the month it's received. For example, the February ratio divides the chargebacks received in February by the transactions from January.

Excessive Chargeback Program (ECP) thresholds

A business must meet both the chargeback count and the ratio for a level.

LevelMonthly chargebacksChargeback ratio
Excessive Chargeback Merchant (ECM)100 to 2991.5% to 2.99%
High Excessive Chargeback Merchant (HECM)300 or more3% or higher
January transactionsFebruary chargebacksChargeback ratioResult
10,000180180 ÷ 10,000 = 1.8%Excessive Chargeback Merchant (ECM). Both thresholds are met.
10,000320320 ÷ 10,000 = 3.2%High Excessive Chargeback Merchant (HECM). Both thresholds are met.
4,0009090 ÷ 4,000 = 2.25%Threshold not met. The count is below 100.
50,000400400 ÷ 50,000 = 0.8%Threshold not met. The ratio is below 1.5%.

Excessive Chargeback Program (ECP) assessments

Assessments start in the second month a business is above the thresholds and increase the longer it stays there.

Months above the thresholdsExcessive Chargeback Merchant (ECM) assessmentHigh Excessive Chargeback Merchant (HECM) assessmentIssuer recovery assessment
1$0$0No
2$1,000$1,000No
3$1,000$2,000No
4 to 6$5,000$10,000Yes
7 to 11$25,000$50,000Yes
12 to 18$50,000$100,000Yes
19 or more$100,000$200,000Yes

From the fourth month, Mastercard adds an issuer recovery assessment of $5 for each chargeback over 300 in the month.

A business exits the Excessive Chargeback Program (ECP) when it stays below the thresholds for three consecutive months. A business in High Excessive Chargeback Merchant (HECM) that drops below the High Excessive Chargeback Merchant (HECM) thresholds but still meets the Excessive Chargeback Merchant (ECM) thresholds moves to Excessive Chargeback Merchant (ECM).

Excessive Fraud Merchant (EFM)

The Excessive Fraud Merchant (EFM) program monitors fraud chargebacks on online payments. It targets businesses with high fraud that aren't using 3D Secure (3DS) to authenticate buyers.

How the fraud chargeback ratio is calculated

Mastercard fraud chargeback ratio
Fraud chargeback ratio = fraud chargebacks received this month ÷ e-commerce transactions from the previous month

The calculation works like the Excessive Chargeback Program (ECP) ratio, but it counts only fraud chargebacks. Fraud chargebacks are Mastercard chargebacks with reason code 4837 (No Cardholder Authorization) or 4863 (Cardholder Does Not Recognize).

Excessive Fraud Merchant (EFM) thresholds

A business is placed in the program when all four thresholds are met in a month:

CriteriaThreshold
E-commerce Mastercard transactions1,000 or more
Fraud chargeback amount$50,000 or more
Fraud chargeback ratio0.50% or higher (50 basis points)
Share of Mastercard transactions authenticated with 3D Secure (3DS)10% or less

The 3D Secure (3DS) threshold depends on the region. In the United States and Canada, a business that authenticates more than 10% of its Mastercard payments with 3DS isn't placed in Excessive Fraud Merchant (EFM). In Europe, where regulation requires authentication, the cutoff is 50%.

Excessive Fraud Merchant (EFM) assessments

Months above the thresholdsAssessment
1$0
2$500
3$1,000
4 to 6$5,000
7 to 11$25,000
12 to 18$50,000
19 or more$100,000

A business exits Excessive Fraud Merchant (EFM) when it stays below the thresholds for three consecutive months.

A business that meets both the Excessive Fraud Merchant (EFM) and Excessive Chargeback Program (ECP) thresholds in the same month is assessed only for Excessive Fraud Merchant (EFM). Mastercard keeps tracking both programs, so the months still count toward the Excessive Chargeback Program (ECP) if the business later meets only the Excessive Chargeback Program (ECP) thresholds.

Questionable Merchant Audit Program (QMAP)

The Questionable Merchant Audit Program (QMAP) identifies businesses that take part in fraud themselves, as opposed to businesses that are victims of it. It covers two patterns:

  • Bust-out fraud: The business and a cardholder work together to run up charges that the cardholder never intends to pay.
  • Other fraudulent activity: The business knowingly processes payments on stolen or counterfeit cards.

The Questionable Merchant Audit Program (QMAP) has no monthly ratio. Mastercard opens a case when a business's activity over a review period meets the program thresholds:

CriteriaThreshold
Review periodUp to 120 days
Mastercard volume in the review period$50,000 or more
Mastercard transactions in the review period5 or more
Bust-out cases50% or more of the business's volume is on bust-out accounts.
Other casesMastercard also applies fraud, decline, and referral tests. These tests change on April 1, 2027.

When Mastercard confirms a case, the issuing banks can recover their losses through chargebacks with reason code 4849 (Questionable Merchant Activity), and Mastercard charges the acquirer an audit fee. A confirmed case usually ends the business's ability to accept cards.

Changes on April 1, 2027

Mastercard has announced changes to the Questionable Merchant Audit Program (QMAP) and to its chargeback monitoring standards that take effect on April 1, 2027. This page describes the programs in effect today.

Business Risk Assessment and Mitigation (BRAM)

The Business Risk Assessment and Mitigation (BRAM) program protects the Mastercard network and brand from illegal and brand-damaging transactions. Like the Visa Integrity Risk Program (VIRP), it has no ratio. Mastercard charges non-compliance assessments when a business processes prohibited activity.

Mastercard sets each Business Risk Assessment and Mitigation (BRAM) assessment case by case.

Global Risk Investigation Program (GRIP)

The Global Risk Investigation Program (GRIP), which Mastercard also calls the Global Rules Investigation Program, investigates possible violations of the Mastercard rules that fall outside its other programs. The program is case-driven. It has no ratio and no threshold.

In a Global Risk Investigation Program (GRIP) case, Mastercard sends the acquirer an investigation notice. The acquirer confirms the facts with the business and either shows that the business is compliant or submits a plan to correct the issue. If the issue isn't corrected, Mastercard charges assessments that increase until it is. A business can request a review of an assessment, which may be subject to an assessment or fee.

Global Risk Investigation Program (GRIP) investigations have short deadlines. If Finix contacts you about one, respond with the requested information by the date in the notice.

American Express

American Express monitors chargebacks through its Excessive Chargeback fee.

ProgramTypeWhat it monitors
Excessive chargebacksDispute and fraudChargebacks of any kind.

American Express non-compliance assessments can be passed through to you and your merchants.

Excessive chargebacks

American Express chargeback ratio
Chargeback ratio = (chargebacks − chargeback reversals) ÷ (gross charges − credits)

All inputs come from the same calendar month. A chargeback reversal is a chargeback that American Express returns to the business after the business wins the dispute. Unlike Visa and Mastercard, American Express gives credit for disputes that are won.

American Express applies the Excessive Chargeback fee when the ratio is above 1% for three consecutive months.

CriteriaThreshold
Chargeback ratioAbove 1%
DurationThree consecutive months
Fee$25 for each chargeback, less reversals, above the 1% ratio, in each month after the threshold is met.

American Express also runs programs that change how chargebacks are handled for a business with high fraud or dispute levels:

  • Fraud Full Recourse Program: The business can no longer challenge fraud chargebacks.
  • Immediate Chargeback Program: American Express debits the business for disputes other than fraud without first sending an inquiry.

Discover

Discover monitors disputes in two ways. It can charge a fee to businesses with a high volume of disputes, and it reviews fraud disputes separately.

ProgramTypeWhat it monitors
Excessive disputesDispute and fraudDisputes of any kind.
Fraud dispute levelsDispute and fraudFraud disputes.

Excessive disputes

Discover may charge an excessive dispute fee when a business has a high volume of disputes. Finix notifies you if a fee applies.

The Discover dispute ratio uses dollar amounts. The Visa VAMP and Mastercard chargeback ratios use counts.

Discover dispute ratio
Dispute ratio = dispute amount ÷ net sales amount

Both amounts come from the same calendar month. Net sales are Discover card sales minus returns.

Fraud dispute levels

Discover also reviews fraud dispute levels, where the cardholder says they didn't authorize the payment. It measures two ratios:

Discover fraud dispute ratios
Fraud count ratio = fraud disputes ÷ sales transactions
Fraud amount ratio = fraud dispute amount ÷ sales amount

Discover doesn't publish thresholds for these ratios. It sets them by industry and adjusts them as fraud trends shift. A business that goes over the level for its industry is asked to provide a remediation plan.

Staying below the thresholds

Track your ratios every month so a rising trend doesn't surprise you. Count the disputes you received in the month for each card network and divide by that network's transactions, using the formulas on this page.

These practices lower dispute and fraud ratios:

  • Early fraud checks: Stop fraud before the payment is captured. Use address and security code checks to decline or review risky payments. For more information, see Risk Rules and Card Checks.
  • 3D Secure authentication: Authenticating buyers with 3D Secure reduces fraud and shifts liability for most fraud disputes to the issuing bank. For more information, see 3D Secure.
  • Quick refunds: Refund quickly when a buyer complains. A refund issued before the buyer contacts their bank prevents the dispute. It doesn't prevent a fraud report, which still counts toward Visa VAMP.
  • Recognizable charges: A clear statement descriptor and visible contact details prevent disputes that start as confusion. For more information, see Preventing disputes.
  • Accurate details: Tell Finix before you change what you sell or how you sell it, so your merchant category code and descriptor stay correct.

What happens when a business is placed in a program

The details vary by program, but the process follows the same general pattern:

  • The network notifies Finix (the acquirer) and Finix notifies you.
  • You or your merchants provide a remediation plan that explains the cause and the steps you're taking to fix it.
  • The network charges assessments or fees for each month the business stays above the thresholds. The networks bill these to Finix, and they can be passed on to the business that caused them.
  • The business stays in the program until it's below the thresholds for the required period, which is three consecutive months for the Mastercard chargeback programs.
  • If the problem isn't fixed, the network can require Finix to stop processing for your business or your merchants. A terminated business can be added to the industry lists that other acquirers check before they approve a new account, such as Mastercard's MATCH list.

Next steps